Wednesday, Jan 16th

Last updateWed, 16 Jan 2019 11am

You are here: Home Content On Our Radar Addressing the Lawsuit Against the Village of Scarsdale and Scarsdale Police Department
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
Where Your Village Taxes Go

Where Your Village Taxes Go

Though the portion of your real estate taxes that goes to Scarsdale Village only...

Cannon to Leave School Board, District Announces Retirement of Administrator and Teachers

Cannon to Leave School Board, District Announces Retirement of Administrator and Teachers

Nina Cannon Both her board colleagues and the administration appeared to be surpr...

Jill Spieler to Receive the 2019 Scarsdale Bowl Award

Jill Spieler to Receive the 2019 Scarsdale Bowl Award

Jill Spieler will receive the 2019 Scarsdale Bowl Jill Spieler, an extraordinary ...

Dine Like Royalty at the New Z Prime Italian Steakhouse

Dine Like Royalty at the New Z Prime Italian Steakhouse

At a time when everything seems to be rushed, it’s a joy to enter the new and st...

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Addressing the Lawsuit Against the Village of Scarsdale and Scarsdale Police Department

podiumThe following remarks were given at the Board of Trustee meeting on February 13, 2018. The comments are the personal views of Ron Schulhof.

I would like to talk tonight about the recent lawsuit filed by Robert Berg against the Village of Scarsdale and the Scarsdale Police Department over lawn signs. I'm not going to opine on whether lawn signs are good or bad or the legality of this issue, but rather HOW this issue was addressed. I think it's important to address this situation because how we do things as a community matters.

When I first heard that someone sued our police department over this issue I was shocked and dismayed because the placement of lawn signs is an issue that could have been brought up and resolved in a constructive and open manner. This issue could have been handled without making it political and without litigation.

The issue in question is a section of our Village code. Village code can be changed and certainly can be done without needing a lawsuit to change it. The lawsuit states that the suing party believed there was an issue with lawn signs almost a year ago! This means that anytime over the last year this issue could have been brought up and we could have addressed this as a community. Anytime over the last many months would have been the time to jump into action. This would have given an opportunity for anyone who wanted to be involved to get informed and voice their opinion. Change could have been made in a way that was open, collaborative and constructive.

Why do it this way - in a last minute, aggressive and litigious manner. Everybody should consider for themselves the potential motives for the situation being handled in this way. My personal view, it was simply laziness. Doing it right would have likely taken much more work. It would have been a lot of work to bring this up months ago and work collaboratively with the Village, Board and Community. It would have taken effort and time to discuss the issue and all the relevant points - legal and otherwise. Time which we would have had, since it wouldn't have been done in the last minute. It would have been worth it! Giving others in the community a chance to voice their views and thoughts and work through this issue. If there is concern that this isn't how things happen in Scarsdale or if there is a concern with the process of how code changes happen, then this could have been a shining example of how to do it better. How we do things matters.

If this had been done in a timely and constructive way, our police chief wouldn't be faced with possibly spending his time in a deposition room. Our Village wouldn't need to spend money and resources to respond in court. The community, as a whole, could have been involved in the discussion. Whatever your view on this issue, we should strive to make sure everyone has an opportunity to be involved in such important issues. Instead, the discussion is now centered around a lawsuit.

We work through many issues and proposals here - and one of the great things about our community is how we work through them with an open dialogue and collaboratively. I have personally brought many proposals before the Board and the community feedback we receive always makes them better. Scarsdale is a great place to live. Lawsuits are not what makes Scarsdale great.

Our Village now may end up spending time, money and resources in the legal system because of this lawsuit. So we're here now - what can we do? I would urge members of our community to consider sending a note of support to our Police Department. I personally sent them one this weekend. I think it's important we let our Police Department know the actions of one individual, in suing them in this manner, do not represent who we are as a community. The Police Department is not some faceless organization. We are a small town and our officers are part of this community; suing our police department over an issue that could have been handled otherwise is not an action of appreciation or respect for our police department and the officers that work hard every day for this community. Actions matter.

Going forward, we can simply be better than using lawsuits when there are other options available. While we can't control the actions of one person, the rest of us can do the hard work, the detailed work, the unglamorous work, in a manner that continues to make Scarsdale a fantastic place.

Ron Schulhof
February 13, 2018

Disclosure Statement: I am a member of the following Village and Civic organizations: Citizens Nominating Committee, Scarsdale Citizens Non-Partisan Party, Conservation Advisory Council (Chair), LED Streetlight Committee (Chair), Food Scrap Recycling Committee, Scarsdale Forum chilepepper(Board of Directors). The comments are my own personal views.

Want to post a comment? Please include your REAL name and street address.

Good Work

SETTING

Scarsdale’s Legislators Engel and Stewart-Cousins in the Spotlight this Week

Scarsdale’s Legislators Engel and Stewart-Cousins in the Spotlight this Week

Two of Scarsdale’s representatives are making headlines this week. Now that Democrats control the House of Representatives, Rep. Eliot Engel (D-N.Y.), w...

Read More

Around Town

SETTING

Public Comments Invited on Freightway Development January 22

Public Comments Invited on Freightway Development January 22

( From Scarsdale Village ) The Village of Scarsdale Committee of the Whole will convene a meeting on Tuesday, January 22, 2019 to garner public comments...

Read More

Neighborhood News

SETTING

Edgewood's Joyous Centennial Celebration

Edgewood's Joyous Centennial Celebration

Edgewood School’s 100-year celebration on Monday January 7, 2018 was an uplifting event that concluded with the long-anticipated time opening of the t...

Read More

On Our Minds

SETTING

A Poet and a President

A Poet and a President

On Sunday February 10th at 3pm the Scarsdale Forum, the League of Women Voters Scarsdale and the Scarsdale Library will be screening the film JFK: The...

Read More

On Our Radar

SETTING

Scarsdale Girls’ Varsity Basketball Team Now 5-5 and Shooting for the Playoffs

Scarsdale Girls’ Varsity Basketball Team Now 5-5 and Shooting for the Playoffs

Captain Kayla Maroney '20 shooting a free throw The Scarsdale Girls Varsity Basketball team has had a solid season so far with a record of 5-5. When fi...

Read More

Parenting

SETTING

Scarsdale Boys’ Basketball’s Thrilling Season

Scarsdale Boys’ Basketball’s Thrilling Season

SHS Boys’ Varsity Basketball has had an energizing start to their season under first-year coach Joe Amelio.

Over the summer, Coach Joe Amelio of St. Ra...

Read More

Village Voices

SETTING

Where Your Village Taxes Go

Where Your Village Taxes Go

Though the portion of your real estate taxes that goes to Scarsdale Village only accounts for 18.3% of the total bill, the services they fund are perh...

Read More

Shout it Out

SETTING

You're Invited to Join the Procedure Committee

You're Invited to Join the Procedure Committee

The Procedure Committee begins a new season administering the non-partisan village office election system next month on February 1. The PC is currentl...

Read More

School News

SETTING

Demographer Provides 5-Year Enrollment Projection for the Scarsdale Schools

Demographer Provides 5-Year Enrollment Projection for the Scarsdale Schools

It was somewhat of a surprise last spring to learn that projected enrollment for kindergarten in Scarsdale was down – way down. Though traditionally e...

Read More

Schools

SETTING

Cannon to Leave School Board, District Announces Retirement of Administrator and Teachers

Cannon to Leave School Board, District Announces Retirement of Administrator and Teachers

Nina Cannon Both her board colleagues and the administration appeared to be surprised by school board member Nina Cannon’s announcement at the BOE meet...

Read More

The Goods

SETTING

Boys Hockey Gaining Momentum on the Ice

Boys Hockey Gaining Momentum on the Ice

Scarsdale Boys Varsity Hockey team is gaining momentum that could potentially carry them deep into the playoffs.

The Raiders have been riddled with inj...

Read More

Real Estate

SETTING

Economic Woes Take Their Toll on Home Sales in Scarsdale

Economic Woes Take Their Toll on Home Sales in Scarsdale

A teardown at 39 Church Lane The numbers are in – and they confirm what many feared. The new tax law, economic uncertainty and demographic trends have ...

Read More

Today's News

SETTING

Police Report: Bronx Driver Arrested for DWI, Dog Bites Fed Ex Man

Police Report: Bronx Driver Arrested for DWI, Dog Bites Fed Ex Man

DWI arrest: On Jan. 5 at 4:18 am, police arrested Ruben Mendoza Alvarado, 27, of the Bronx, on charges of driving while intoxicated (first offense), o...

Read More

Arts and Entertainment

SETTING

Dine Like Royalty at the New Z Prime Italian Steakhouse

Dine Like Royalty at the New Z Prime Italian Steakhouse

At a time when everything seems to be rushed, it’s a joy to enter the new and stunning Z Prime Italian Steakhouse , to enjoy an upscale meal served with...

Read More

People

SETTING

Jill Spieler to Receive the 2019 Scarsdale Bowl Award

Jill Spieler to Receive the 2019 Scarsdale Bowl Award

Jill Spieler will receive the 2019 Scarsdale Bowl Jill Spieler, an extraordinary resident with 40 years of dedicated volunteerism to Scarsdale, will be...

Read More

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Programs for Scarsdale Kids