Monday, Jun 18th

Last updateMon, 18 Jun 2018 9am

You are here: Home Content School News Consultants to be Hired to Review the Village Assessor's Office
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
Teens Taunt Police at Unsupervised Party

Teens Taunt Police at Unsupervised Party

At approximately 10:20 p.m., June 10, police responded to a noise c...

District Failed to Disclose Mold Testing Results Before Bond Referendum

District Failed to Disclose Mold Testing Results Before Bond Referendum

The question about mold at Greenacres School has resurfaced again. ...

Committee Recommends Using EPDM Infill for Replacement of Synthetic Turf at Butler Field

Committee Recommends Using EPDM Infill for Replacement of Synthetic Turf at Butler Field

The Butler Field Committee comprised of administrators, coaches, pa...

New SMS House Counselor Brings Unique Skills to the Job

New SMS House Counselor Brings Unique Skills to the Job

Michael Williams will join the SMS Team as Cooper House Counselor Mi...

Adventure Travel with Kids: Costa Rica

Adventure Travel with Kids: Costa Rica

Costa Rica has become a top adventure travel destination for Americ...

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Consultants to be Hired to Review the Village Assessor's Office

realestatetaxesIt seemed like old times at Village Hall on Tuesday night June 6 when some of the most vocal opponents of the 2016 revaluation returned for a meeting on hiring a consultant to conduct an independent review of the Village Assessor's office. The Village held a similar meeting with the consulting firm Management Partners in late February, but at the time the trustees decided to wait to make a decision on retaining them until they could answer more questions on their expertise on revaluations.

Kevin Knutson from Management Partners explained that he was a former Village Manager of Coral Gables Florida who now works at Management Partners, an 85-person firm with over 700 clients in 41 states. All of the firms' employees formerly worked in government. For this meeting, Knutson brought in Thomas Frey, who has worked as an assessor, appraiser and as a project consultant on a revaluation in Mamaroneck to serve as a technical consultant on the work in Scarsdale.

The consultants will be charged with doing a review of the assessor's office, evaluating practices and processes with an eye toward improving their efficiency and effectiveness. Village Manager Steve Pappalardo said, "The study will not involve forensic evaluations of the Tyler and Ryan models," but will be an analysis to help improve processes. The project is anticipated to take four to five months to complete and the consultants would be paid $34,990 which will come out of the FY 2016-17 budget.

Frey introduced himself, explaining that he has been an assessor for 42 years, worked as an assessor for a municipality for 32 years and also as an instructor in the field. He has worked as a consultant for the City of White Plains and did appraisals for SCARS hearings. In Mamaroneck, he was the Project Manager for what he called a "reasonably successful" revaluation. When asked what he believed was the key to a good revaluation, Frey said, "...Explain what you are going to do and be as transparent as possible." Asked what he has seen as issues with the assessor's offices in other towns, he said, "They often don't have enough staffing." In response to a question about his role in Mamaroneck he said, "I worked on the RFP, met with contractor and the assessors office, communicated with the town board and rechecked samples of the data collection ... serving as the monitor."

Frey also commented on whether it was possible to conduct a revaluation without doing another round of data collection. He said, "Yes, as long as you maintain good records of sales and demolitions. Sometimes you can just "tweak" the values."
He said he did that within the office without hiring an outside firm. The comment about "tweaking" brought to mind Ryan's claim before he conducted the 2016 revaluation, using data collected for the prior revaluation in 2014.

Mayor Hochvert asked, "How do you fairly assess the quality and condition of a home? How do you develop these parameters? What does the range denote? AAA? C? Frey responded, "Condition and quality are the hardest to do – as they are subjective. Simplifying the grade is better. When the range gets too big it is hard to keep consistency." He added, "We do mass appraisal. We aim toward the middle and go up or down from there."

Amy Parlato wanted to know how Frey would get feedback, and the consultants said they would visit the office 4-5 times and interview residents. Mayra Kirkendall Rodriguez wanted to know what model Frey worked with when he was an assessor and he explained that he used "a model provided from New York State and adjusted for our municipality that worked with the RPS system." Asked if he back tested the model, he said yes.

About the diversity of the housing stock he explained that Mamaroneck was similar to Scarsdale in the range of housing. To another question from Steve Rakoff about what to do when there is a shortage of comparable sales during a specific period, Frey said that the office extends the sales period to gather more values. His wife Amy asked if Frey was aware of the situation in Scarsdale and he said that all he knew was what he read in the media.

At one point, the clear divide in opinion about future revaluations surfaced in the room; Bob Berg affirmed his desire for the consultants to work independently to analyze and make their recommendations and said, "I think we all agree that we need to do another revaluation in the near future," which brought cries of disagreement from Ron Parlato and Steve Rakoff who said, "No we don't... don't speak for us!"

Michael Levine who is a statistician commented that it would be difficult to separate problems in the assessor's office with issues with the models used. He said to the consultants, "I understand that this is a limited engagement. You may think you can get at this by analyzing the procedures. But below it is perceived flaws in the results that resulted from perceived flaws in the methodology or land evaluation. You will get into these questions. I suggest you anticipate this and when you see it you don't ignore it. Notice that and be aware – even if it's outside the scope of your work."

At the conclusion of the meeting it appeared that both the trustees and community members in attendance were in agreement that the consultants should be retained to do the study.  Following the meeting, the trustees asked village managers to draft a resolution to hire the consultants. This will be voted on at the June 13th meeting of the board of trustees. 

BLOG COMMENTS POWERED BY DISQUS

Good Work

SETTING

Palmieri Muses on Hillary's Loss and What it Means for Women in Politics

Palmieri Muses on Hillary's Loss and What it Means for Women in Politics

Chris Riback, Jennifer Palmieri and SAS Director Jill Serling Why did Hillary lose the election, how did Trump dominate the media and what...

Read More

Around Town

SETTING

The June 26th Congressional Primary Election: What You Should Know

The June 26th Congressional Primary Election: What You Should Know

Many of us are receiving lots of mail from the Democratic candidates running in the June 26th primary for Congress for the 16th district....

Read More

Neighborhood News

SETTING

Sign Petitions to Put Candidates on the Ballot

Sign Petitions to Put Candidates on the Ballot

June 16, 2018

Letter to the Editor
This week starting June 16 and running until July 10, 2018 people will be coming to your door and asking...

Read More

On Our Minds

SETTING

New SMS House Counselor Brings Unique Skills to the Job

New SMS House Counselor Brings Unique Skills to the Job

Michael Williams will join the SMS Team as Cooper House Counselor Michael Williams will be the new House Counselor for Cooper House at Sca...

Read More

On Our Radar

SETTING

Teens Taunt Police at Unsupervised Party

Teens Taunt Police at Unsupervised Party

At approximately 10:20 p.m., June 10, police responded to a noise complaint related to a party on Berkley Road. Patrol attempted to make ...

Read More

Parenting

SETTING

Adventure Travel with Kids: Costa Rica

Adventure Travel with Kids: Costa Rica

Costa Rica has become a top adventure travel destination for American families. In under five hours from a New York area airport (we chos...

Read More

Village Voices

SETTING

Board of Trustees Approves Gift Reserve Fund Tax Credit and Hears Heated Public Comments

Board of Trustees Approves Gift Reserve Fund Tax Credit and Hears Heated Public Comments

Following a public hearing this past Tuesday, the Scarsdale Board of Trustees approved the establishment of a charitable gift reserve fun...

Read More

Shout it Out

SETTING

Photo Opps: SHS Alum Named Presidential Scholar at Cornell, Scouts Honored

Photo Opps: SHS Alum Named Presidential Scholar at Cornell, Scouts Honored

 

Joshua Klein, Larry Brown and Allison Weiner Heinemann with Provost Michael Kotlikoff Scarsdale native, Joshua Klein, was recently h...

Read More

School News

SETTING

Meet Christopher Welsh, Incoming Assistant Principal at SHS

Meet Christopher Welsh, Incoming Assistant Principal at SHS

Chris Welsh will become an Assistant Principal at Scarsdale High School in July. Christopher Welsh will join the administrative team as an...

Read More

Schools

SETTING

Committee Recommends Using EPDM Infill for Replacement of Synthetic Turf at Butler Field

Committee Recommends Using EPDM Infill for Replacement of Synthetic Turf at Butler Field

The Butler Field Committee comprised of administrators, coaches, parents and students was convened to analyze options for replacement of ...

Read More

The Goods

SETTING

District Failed to Disclose Mold Testing Results Before Bond Referendum

District Failed to Disclose Mold Testing Results Before Bond Referendum

The question about mold at Greenacres School has resurfaced again. At the May 21 meeting of the Scarsdale Board of Education, Greenacres ...

Read More

Real Estate

SETTING

Real Estate: Trustees Prioritize Changes to Land Use Code and Procedures

Real Estate: Trustees Prioritize Changes to Land Use Code and Procedures

Village Trustees are taking steps to re-examine aspects of local zoning code in an effort to reduce the number of teardowns and the bulk ...

Read More

Today's News

SETTING

Police Report: Firefighters Battle House Fire on Tunstall Road.

Police Report: Firefighters Battle House Fire on Tunstall Road.

Fire on Tunstall Road

On June 8, fire was reported in a Tunstall Road house. Upon arrival, firefighters noted the house was completely fil...

Read More

Arts and Entertainment

SETTING

Argentinean and Italian Cuisine Expertly Combined at Magno’s Grill

Argentinean and Italian Cuisine Expertly Combined at Magno’s Grill

In my restaurant travels through the years, some spots have a special place in my memory. Many years ago I savored many fine meals at Tan...

Read More

People

SETTING

School District Recognizes June Retirees

School District Recognizes June Retirees

Many longtime teachers and administrators who will retire at the end of the this school year were recognized at a ceremony prior to the B...

Read More

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Programs for Scarsdale Kids