Wednesday, Oct 18th

Last updateTue, 17 Oct 2017 1pm

You are here: Home Scarsale Gardens Greenacres: Relocation Options, Including Modular Classrooms, Must Be Part of Bond Planning
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Greenacres: Relocation Options, Including Modular Classrooms, Must Be Part of Bond Planning

modularclassroomThis letter to the editor was sent to Scarsdale10583.com by Greenacres resident Sara Cetron:
The Greenacres Elementary Task Force, a group of concerned Greenacres parents and their supporters from across Scarsdale, have been advocating for the relocation of all Greenacres students off-site during a large construction project expected to begin in 2019.

Shockingly, at the September 11th School Board meeting, only one Board Member spoke in favor of even studying relocation options, despite a petition signed by hundreds of Scarsdale residents, frequent advocacy in the press and requests to the Board from concerned residents.

Why is the Board so reluctant to even think about relocating Greenacres' kids? The Board appears to misunderstand types of relocation options available as well as their costs and benefits. Let's review the reasons that several Board Members gave for not wanting to even consider relocation to show why they are misinformed:

"Relocation Isn't Better Than Being in the School Building" -- Relocation is much better because it keeps the kids as far away from construction as possible rather than forcing them to learn, travel and play next to it every school day for more than a year. This may come as a surprise to District administrators who already enjoy modern comforts such as air conditioning, but modular classrooms are significantly better than the conditions at Greenacres school. Nice modulars are modern with comforts like air conditioning that won't be found in most Greenacres classrooms even after a $40 million project! They have modern bathrooms, great lighting and are built with green materials. Modulars are not meant to replace permanent structures, though some cash-strapped school districts (not Scarsdale) use them for that, but modulars are certainly a modern, healthy and desirable choice and preferable to keeping kids in the construction zone.

"It's Financially Unfeasible" -- It's difficult to see how such a determination could be made until specific options have been studied and priced out, but the current plan budgets $1.5 million for 8 modular classrooms (about 2 grades) on the Greenacres field. To accommodate the rest of the regular classrooms at Greenacres, add another 16 classrooms for $3 million. $1.5 million has already been budgeted for Greenacres field restoration -- that can be used for site work. Modular classroom should be located at the back of the field as far away from the construction as possible. A temporary playground should be installed next to the modulars so that no child has to go near the construction to play. Can Scarsdale afford this? Of course it can, but it all comes down to priorities. The bond currently budgets $1.4 million for a baseball field renovation at the high school. That amount could fund half of the additional modular classrooms for Greenacres. If the School Board were interested in relocation, they could find a way to fund it. As Task Force member Tony Corriggio pointed out to the Board during public comment, there is the potential for cost savings if relocation allows all of the Greenacres work to be done at one time rather than spread out over several years. Contractors may offer better bids which would lower costs for the entire project, which is why these options must be studied in detail by the Board.

"We've Done Construction Before Without Relocation" -- Scarsdale has never done a project of this scale at a school this old on such a tight site plan and with kids this close. You can't compare this project with other District work that involved a corner of a building on a much larger lot. Greenacres' site is tiny, and this project covers the entire front of the school and the kids' play area next to their playground, leaving them right in the middle of construction.

"The Consultants Say It's Not Necessary" -- The District administration has steered their paid consultants toward a particular path for this project. If the School Board had asked for relocation options, the consultants would be talking about them.

The reason there is so much unfamiliarity with these options, even among members of the School Board, is that relocation options haven't been properly studied or discussed.

Time is running out to finalize these plans before the bond is presented to Scarsdale voters. But it's not too late for the School Board to change course and show that it wants to work in good faith to address significant concerns and pursue all potential options for relocation. These options, including modular classrooms, must be a major part of bond planning going forward.

Sincerely,

Sara Cetron
Greenacres Resident

Comments   

+3 #12 Resident 2017-09-28 19:01
If the scale of the Greenacres renovation is so large, then I think the residents should be voting this down. The school is small, and the population declined this year.
Quote
+7 #11 Greenacrs mom 2017-09-27 11:33
It seems no one cares about the safety and health of Greenacres children other than their parents. it's typical of Scarsdale... just like when parents speed on streets where their kids don't live on
Quote
+12 #10 the real questions 2017-09-26 14:21
Quoting B. Dirk:
It is incredible that the Greenacres and District Wide facilities committees are closed, not recorded, and no minutes are available to the public. Who is paying the Administration's salary? It is incredible that Scarsdale residents put up with this kind of undemocratic behavior. This helps perpetuate the myth that Scarsdale schools are great, when in reality, there are plenty of schools that are better locally and nationwide.


Minutes are posted online. But they are administration minutes. And unlike minutes in the real world they do not list those present.

The real questions are:
Why are Board members on the Greenacres building committee?
Isn't this micromanaging? And does this really allow local building committee members, including faculty, to speak freely and openly about what they really think?

Why are districtwide committee meetings being held at 3 o'clock in the afternoon? In the past such a committee has included community members with actual related expertise in construction, architecture, etc., many of whom work during the day. Is this bond getting the kind of scrutiny from community members with an informed perspective that past bonds have received?

Who actually likes the design plan for Greenacres?
Aren't we supposed to be even mildly excited to spend $35 million?
Quote
+13 #9 B. Dirk 2017-09-25 16:01
It is incredible that the Greenacres and District Wide facilities committees are closed, not recorded, and no minutes are available to the public. Who is paying the Administration' s salary? It is incredible that Scarsdale residents put up with this kind of undemocratic behavior. This helps perpetuate the myth that Scarsdale schools are great, when in reality, there are plenty of schools that are better locally and nationwide.
Quote
+11 #8 Environmentally Safe School 2017-09-25 11:04
We should not have to trade trailers for a clean, healthy school. Demand new pipes, no lead, no mildew and mold. Don't accept less.
Quote
+14 #7 Please lets come together 2017-09-24 21:00
For people who wanted a new school, I hope you could live with a renovation with trailers.

For people who wanted a renovation, hopefully you can give a little to get everyone on board who is concerned about noise and safety.

Please can we all come together as a community around a plan such as this.
Quote
+18 #6 Clarification 2017-09-24 20:56
Trailers do NOT mean no specials. A modular rooms for art, music, etc. would be included. This has been done successfully across the country with very good results. My niece was in a modular classroom three years ago and it was very nice, with little noise disturbance from the construction and fully safety.

Doing this would be a great compromise, so that everyone could rally around a renovation with no more infighting.
Quote
+12 #5 To Please lets come together 2017-09-24 17:54
I really agree that it would be great if everyone could bury the hatchet and rally around a compromise plan.

If five die-hard new schoolers and five save-the-fielde rs could write to the board saying that they would get behind a renovation plus modular classrooms plan, I think it would go a long way.

I know renovation isn't ideal for some. I know that modular classrooms aren't ideal for some. But this has to end somehow, and its time for the community to return to they way it was.

Please think about this as a reasonable path forward, even if it's not your first choice.
Quote
-15 #4 Greenacres parent 2017-09-24 16:47
I agree. Thank you for this approach, but it is still one sided... Trailers will mean no specials.No art? No music? No PE? How is this better for our children? The board of ed has hired on site independent specialists to monitor the air, sound and safety of our children. How are trailers better than Keeping them safe in their classrooms? With all the benefits they deserve. Where's the other article with the other half of this story.
Quote
+20 #3 Polly Klein 2017-09-24 12:20
Thank you, Sara for this informative letter about keeping the kids of Greenacres safe during construction. I do believe the community has moved past the renovate vs. build new debate and now we've accepted the renovation and the whole community just wants to keep the children safe, in trailers and as far away from the construction as possible. If this bond is ever going to pass, trailers for the duration of the entire project need to be budgeted into this renovation.
Quote

Add comment

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop