Sunday, Dec 09th

Last updateThu, 06 Dec 2018 12pm

You are here: Home Content Neighborhood News Court Dismisses Article 78 Filed by Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
Air Conditioning and School Security on the Agenda at the Scarsdale School Board Meeting

Air Conditioning and School Security on the Agenda at the Scarsdale School Board Meeting

Air conditioning, lunch, facilities and security were top of mind a...

Light the Dale Lights Up Smiles in Scarsdale Village

Light the Dale Lights Up Smiles in Scarsdale Village

There were smiles all around on Friday night November 30 when Santa...

Overhill Neighbors and Scarsdale Friends Remember Bev Sved

Overhill Neighbors and Scarsdale Friends Remember Bev Sved

Memorial Service for Beverley Sved. Photo credit: HL Flisser Scarsda...

Maria: Home Cooked Italian in New Rochelle

Maria: Home Cooked Italian in New Rochelle

“Maria”, I just discovered a restaurant named Maria, and it is quic...

Is 1-on-1 Personal Training for You?

Is 1-on-1 Personal Training for You?

What’s your preferred form of exercise? While some swear by self di...

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Court Dismisses Article 78 Filed by Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments

countycourthouseThe long awaited decision by the court on the Article 78 proceeding filed in January 2017 by the Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments is in: Judge Bruce Tolbert of the Supreme Court of the State of New York denied the Article 78 in its entirety and granted the motion to dismiss.

The Article 78 asked the court to annul, void and rescind the 2016 tax assessment roll for Scarsdale and roll back valuations to 2015 assessments. If the Village failed to roll back the assessments, they asked that the petitioners who would pay more taxes on the 2016 roll than the 2015 roll be refunded the difference.

In April 2017 another group of Scarsdale residents filed a motion to intervene to "correct the false record put forth by the Committee and make clear that "all other taxpayers in the Town/Village of Scarsdale" do not agree that the Committee represents their interests." In fact, the motion says that the intervenors "Object to the Village wasting its time and money defending the Article 78" and also "Object to the prospect of Scarsdale's tax assessment procedure being dictated by a judicial monitor rather than proceeding under the established municipal and state regulatory procedures and administrative remedies that govern residential property tax assessments."

Kevin Reed, one of the attorneys who filed the motion to intervene said, "Our clients filed their motion to intervene in the Article 78 proceeding to make clear to the Court that the self-appointed Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments does not represent all Scarsdale taxpayers. If the motion is granted, our clients will advocate to the Court that that the Article 78 proceeding is without merit, that a rollback of the 2016 assessment would cause the Village more harm than good, and that grievances with the results of the 2016 assessment should be pursued on an individual basis through the administrative and judicial mechanisms provided by New York State law."

In the decision dated 1/5/2018, the court rejected the Committee's Article 78 petition on every front. Most importantly, the court dismissed the Committee's central argument—that the Ryan Revaluation was fundamentally flawed and unfair—holding that the challenge to the Ryan Revaluation was "false[]" and based only on a "vague argument" that amounted to an "idea that 'we liked the first one better.'" The decision says, "There is a lack of substance and empirical data by what is presented by the movant in this matter. Clearly, there is a need of sound theory and objective data which is necessary to overcome the presumption regarding the validity of the challenged assessment."

The court found that the committee lacked standing to plead as they are not "a person or a corporation who is a taxpayer." The decision says, "this formed committee, the Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments, is not a property owner in its own right, nor is it an incorporated entity."

The court also noted that a full-scale roll-back to the Tyler Revaluation would cause "chaos" and "disrupt[ion]" to the Village. The Committee's Equal Protection claim was rejected for the simple reason that "all of the residents of Scarsdale were treated the same" as they were all subject to the same, valid revaluation.

At a more basic level, the court questioned why the Committee chose to proceed through an Article 78 proceeding rather than individual grievances, as many individual Scarsdale residents do every year. This point was reinforced by the intervenors who volunteered to participate in the action on the side of the Village. The court noted that some of the intervenors "saw a raise in their real estate taxes with the 2016 assessment," and "some have sought Article 7 relief as well." The court observed that this stood in contrast to the Committee, whose members could have sought individual relief but instead chose to seek a full-scale roll-back, which was "clearly against any public policy agenda of any municipality including Scarsdale."

Commenting on the dismissal, Scarsdale Village Attorney Wayne Essanason said, "The decision speaks for itself."

You can read the entire decision here

The Committee has 30 days to choose to appeal this decision.

Comments   

#21 Real experts are needed 2018-01-08 11:17
What the village needs is real valuation experts. A forum committee may have some ideas that are useful but will not be a group of experts in this area and may very well be biased.

Quoting Let’s make some progress:
What the forum committee should be working on is a path forward. I’d like to see that report come out soon.

Recounting the history of what happened (which everyone basically knows at this point) is far less useful.

Quoting Interested observer:
I heard from the Mayor (I think it was a meeting last year?) that the Scarsdale Forum was working on a history of the whole Ryan thing. It would be nice to have a summary of what basically happened, hopefully one that doesn't include stuff about some guy who was in jail, or dinners out, etc. but something that basically summarizes the whole episode. When is that coming, or was there some other thing, or has the whole idea of a history been dropped?
Quote
#20 Let’s make some progress 2018-01-08 10:54
What the forum committee should be working on is a path forward. I’d like to see that report come out soon.

Recounting the history of what happened (which everyone basically knows at this point) is far less useful.

Quoting Interested observer:
I heard from the Mayor (I think it was a meeting last year?) that the Scarsdale Forum was working on a history of the whole Ryan thing. It would be nice to have a summary of what basically happened, hopefully one that doesn't include stuff about some guy who was in jail, or dinners out, etc. but something that basically summarizes the whole episode. When is that coming, or was there some other thing, or has the whole idea of a history been dropped?
Quote
#19 Interested observer 2018-01-08 10:41
I heard from the Mayor (I think it was a meeting last year?) that the Scarsdale Forum was working on a history of the whole Ryan thing. It would be nice to have a summary of what basically happened, hopefully one that doesn't include stuff about some guy who was in jail, or dinners out, etc. but something that basically summarizes the whole episode. When is that coming, or was there some other thing, or has the whole idea of a history been dropped?
Quote
#18 Curious 2018-01-06 22:00
I am curious - how much money did the village spend defending this action? Hopefully, it’s not a lot. And hopefully, there won’t be an appeal that will cost ALL of us - the over-assessed, the under-assessed, and the appropriately-a ssessed - more money.
Quote
#17 JW Naked 2018-01-06 18:19
Hey "Misled" person, are you the Art. 78 participant? Either way, please disclose your true name and address. How much "tax suffering" did you incur? What did you do for this community? Your only contribution is that you're active in this rumory and gossipy blog. Maybe we'll be able to collect a few pennies from the blogger to reimburse you for your activism in this community.
Quote
#16 Sure! 2018-01-06 11:13
Quoting We need a break:
This community should not have to suffer through another reval for some time. We need a break from this infighting. Trustees - please hold off.


Of course, you want the trustees to hold off, so that you can enjoy being subsidized by smaller home owners!
Quote
#15 JW Naked 2018-01-06 10:55
This writing is laughable. People have a right to defend themselves either individually or collectively against the tax tyranny that was imposed by the Ryan’s reval. Stop kidding yourself - it’s not over yet. And it will not be over until a new and fair reval will take place.
Quote
#14 Article78Participants 2018-01-06 10:32
Mayra did and does more for this town than any of you. You are just jealous, because you do not have a career and are a loser.
Quote
#13 Lawsuit 2018-01-06 09:52
This lawsuit was a joke and a waste of precious village resources. So glad it is over.
Quote
#12 Take a stand and VOTE NO 2018-01-06 08:20
The reality is that nothing will change in Scarsdale unless voters take a stand and VOTE NO for the bond on February 8.

Our town has a lot of nerve asking people to approve such a gigantic spending package before making any progress at rectifying this reval situation. (The new lack of deductibility is state and local taxes only makes the situation worse. And the school board hasn’t even completed a long term financial plan, which should have been done before the final bond package was set, not after.)

The bottom line is that Voting NO is the only way to really let our voices be heard. If we don’t exercise our vote, nothing will change.

Please tell your friends and neighbors to Vote NO and insist on a fair revaluation for everyone.
Quote

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Good Work

SETTING

Shop Local for 2018 Holiday Gifts

Shop Local for 2018 Holiday Gifts



No need to leave Scarsdale to find great gifts for family, friends, colleagues, neighbors and everyone you wish to thank at the end of th...

Read More

Around Town

SETTING

Light the Dale Lights Up Smiles in Scarsdale Village

Light the Dale Lights Up Smiles in Scarsdale Village

There were smiles all around on Friday night November 30 when Santa arrived in Scarsdale Village on a fire truck and the holiday tree and...

Read More

Neighborhood News

SETTING

Shop & Dine the 'Dale December 6-8

Shop & Dine the 'Dale December 6-8

The Scarsdale Business Alliance (SBA) is proud to announce its First Annual Holiday Shop & Dine the ‘Dale, Thursday, December 6th thr...

Read More

On Our Minds

SETTING

On Our Radar

SETTING

Mobile Parking App May Soon Come to Scarsdale

Mobile Parking App May Soon Come to Scarsdale

Though the Village cannot increase the number of parking spaces in Scarsdale Village, they can make it easier to pay for parking and elim...

Read More

Parenting

SETTING

20th Annual Greenacres Turkey Bowl and Tailgate

20th Annual Greenacres Turkey Bowl and Tailgate

The wind chill temperature was 10 degrees at kickoff time but nothing was going to stop 25 fathers and sons from participating in the 20t...

Read More

Village Voices

SETTING

Developers Offer Promising Ideas for New Freightway

Developers Offer Promising Ideas for New Freightway

Toll Brothers Developers unveiled innovative plans for the development of the Freightway site at a meeting on Tuesday evening 11-27 of the...

Read More

Shout it Out

SETTING

Is 1-on-1 Personal Training for You?

Is 1-on-1 Personal Training for You?

What’s your preferred form of exercise? While some swear by self directed activities like walking, running or swimming, others play racqu...

Read More

School News

SETTING

Schools

SETTING

Environmental Hazards Pose Risks to Children in Schools: Speak Up Now

Environmental Hazards Pose Risks to Children in Schools: Speak Up Now

Coleytown Middle School in Westport is closed due to mold. Two news stories from other school districts came to my attention this week -- ...

Read More

The Goods

SETTING

Village to Install LED Streetlights

Village to Install LED Streetlights

Scarsdale Village will soon replace 1,510 streetlights throughout the Village with energy-efficient LED streetlights. Following a pilot p...

Read More

Real Estate

SETTING

Demolition Derby Continued Plus Sales and Open Houses

Demolition Derby Continued Plus Sales and Open Houses

61Franklin Road Despite slower sales and higher inventory of homes on the market here, builders continue to purchase homes to tear them do...

Read More

Today's News

SETTING

Arts and Entertainment

SETTING

Maria: Home Cooked Italian in New Rochelle

Maria: Home Cooked Italian in New Rochelle

“Maria”, I just discovered a restaurant named Maria, and it is quickly becoming a favorite. I had the pleasure of chatting with the hospi...

Read More

People

SETTING

Overhill Neighbors and Scarsdale Friends Remember Bev Sved

Overhill Neighbors and Scarsdale Friends Remember Bev Sved

Memorial Service for Beverley Sved. Photo credit: HL Flisser Scarsdale Bowl recipient and committed community volunteer Bev Sved was remem...

Read More

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Programs for Scarsdale Kids