Friday, May 26th

Last updateThu, 25 May 2017 11am

You are here: Home The Goods All I Want for Hanukah is Christmas
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

All I Want for Hanukah is Christmas

HanukkahHarryDear Hanukah Harry, The first thing I want this year for Hanukah is Christmas. No offense to my People. I love being Jewish. It's just that Christmas looks like so much fun, don't you think? Anyone who doesn't celebrate it is kidding herself if she says she isn't just a tad bit envious of the hoopla surrounding December 25th. There is a tree to pick out and decorate. There are carols to sing. There is eggnog to drink. There are awful tinsel-covered sweaters to wear.

Harry, at Christmastime, you get to string colored lights on your house and put reindeer antlers on your dog!


Can't I do it just once? For 2012? I promise not to celebrate it for any religious significance, just as the cultural phenom it has become.


Look at it this way. Hollywood has immortalized the Christmas spirit in classic movies like "White Christmas" and "It's a Wonderful Life." They even celebrate the stress of the holiday with movies like "4 Christmases" and "Christmas Vacation." There's "Miracle on 34th Street," and "Elf" and "Scrooged" and "Bad Santa." There's "The Nightmare Before Christmas," "Arthur Christmas" and "The Santa Clause." There's a Home Alone Christmas and a Muppet one, too. Christmas is so mainstreamed, so American! Just like me!

When I tried to think of Hanukah movies, I couldn't come up with a single one. Then I remembered that Adam Sandler, the Patron Saint of Hanukah, had made "8 Crazy Nights" a few years ago, cornering the market on animated Hanukah musicals. But beyond that one, I was stumped. Google was of little help, bringing me to a site that promisingly listed the Top Ten Hanukah movies. Number one on the list was the little-heard-of holiday classic, "Shalom Sesame," in which Grover goes on "an exploration of Jewish traditions and identities."

Is Grover Jewish? Hmm. Did you know this, Harry?


The list fell apart from there, with titles like "Chanukah on Planet Matzah Ball," and "Chanukah and Passover at Bubbe's." Maybe the first hurdle to creating a quintessential seasonal feel-good flick is that no one can agree to a definitive spelling of the holiday. How can we immortalize Chanukah when it's also Hanukah, Harry?


Oy.


In short, if I treat Christmas like one big, over commercialized, jingle-infested Santa mall, can't I celebrate it just this one time?

Pleeeze?


Fine. Moving on.


The next thing I want for Hanukah this year may seem underwhelming to you after the big shanda of my Christmas wish, but here it is, my soul laid bare: I want a second refrigerator to store extra food in my basement.


"I got a second refrigerator in my garage last year, and it changed my life," my friend told me the other day. She actually boasted about it, if truth be told.


If I had a second refrigerator in my basement – or, I could put it in the garage, I suppose - I could buy items in bulk, thereby reducing my carbon footprint and helping Al Gore and the planet. As it is right now, I drive to the supermarket twice or sometimes three times a day in my big stinking SUV. I bet that if I could buy 50 frozen pizza bagels instead of one puny box of 9 at a time, I would be a saner person and the hole in the ozone layer would begin to heal. My kids would never run out of fish sticks or pizza bagels or ice cream, and I'd never have to cook again because all I'd have to do is heat things up or defrost them. I'd spend less time in my car, aimlessly driving around suburbia trying to remember the one thing I forgot to get at the grocery store and more time ranting to the world via my computer. That's what I'd call a win-win.


Lastly, Hanukah Harry, I'd like a personal assistant. It's really hard to keep track of all my little post-it notes with to-do lists scribbled on them. I'd say that 6 out of 10 items get done later rather than sooner, and approximately 1 out of every ten items doesn't get done at all. I would be much more efficient if I could just tell someone else what I need done and have them do it for me.

Think about it this way, Harry: if someone else bought, kept track of, and wrapped my children's 16 Hanukah presents, then I'd have plenty of time to string the lights on my Christmas tree.

gerstenblattColumnist and blogger Julie Gerstenblatt writes with humor and candor about her life in Scarsdale, her friends and family, and the particular demands of motherhood and wifedom in modern-day suburbia. Read about her new book Lauren Takes Leave and keep up with the latest from Julie Gerstenblatt at http://juliegerstenblatt.com

 

Comments   

0 #8 Old timer 2012-12-02 09:59
Merry Christmas to all and to all a good night. :-). Thanks Julie.
Quote
0 #7 GA Mom 2012-12-02 09:22
Oy vey people -- lighten up! Merry Hanukah, Julie!
Quote
0 #6 Anonymous 2012-11-30 07:11
How disrespectful to treat someone else's religion as a commercialized, jingle-fest Santa mall. You are ignorant of the true meaning of Christmas and I am insulted at your flip attitude towards a holiday that you have chosen not to accurately research and report on.
Quote
0 #5 jgerstenblatt 2012-11-30 00:57
@ Credit: After writing my articles, I always google to see what else has been written about my topic. I found Gary Gulman's website but did not think it mattered to use the same title since I'm sure he's not the first person in the history of the world to say this either. I have no idea what the content of his performance is beyond the title. Why give him credit for what I've said?
Quote
0 #4 White Guy 2012-11-29 10:23
Merry Christmas everybody!
Quote
0 #3 not laughing 2012-11-29 08:03
This column is neither funny nor original. You are insulting your own people and Christians who do take seriously the religious aspect of Christmas
Quote
0 #2 Go Ahead! 2012-11-29 07:20
Celebrate Christmas! It has pagan traditions anyways and started as a celebration of the end of the short winter days. Historians believe Christ was born in March anyways. Adopt what you like about it, maybe even the forgotten one: 'this always better to give than receive. Happy holidays to all!
Quote
0 #1 Credit where credit is due 2012-11-29 05:59
The sentiment is common, but the standup comic, Gary Gulman, is the one who gets credit for coining the notion, "alll I want this year for Hanukah is Christmas" with his hilarious 2010 act, "All I Want for Chanukah is Christmas."
Quote

Add comment

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop