Friday, May 03rd

policebroganmatturroScarsdale officially swore in new Police Chief Andrew Matturro at a ceremony at Scarsdale Library on January 22nd at 10:00 am and recognized outgoing Police Chief John Brogan for 37 years of service to the village. About 120 guests attended, and the room was filled with police officers, their families, village officials and staff who came to pay their respects to Brogan, Matturro and four officers who received promotions.

Police Chief John Brogan has dedicated 37 years of service to the community with 12 years as Chief of the department. He noted that Scarsdale has come a long way since February 5th, 1975, his first day on the job in town. At the time, domestic violence was considered a personal issue and driving while intoxicated was a nuisance. Oftentimes police would drive someone home or take their cars keys rather than place them under arrest.

Brogan said he had one goal when he entered the force; and that was "to leave it a little better than he found it." Throughout his tenure, his motto remained the same; he believes that the basic ingredient to good service is "a cop who cares", which Brogan certainly did. He remarked that a good cop "embraces the conscience of the town", and "has empathy", never forgetting that they should treat citizens the same way they'd want themselves and their families to be treated."

Brogan took the opportunity to thank many – including the trustees, Mayor Bob Steves, officials, the staff and Village Manager Al Gatta, for their guidance and cooperation over the years. He didn't forget to thank family and friends for their stellar support either, knowing that he couldn't have done it without any of them. He thanked his command staff for allowing him to have complete faith that they'd always give him the right answers, even when it wasn't what he wanted to hear. He expressed gratitude to all the men and women of the department for being "the manifestation of the motto SPD; service, pride, dedication." 

Chief Brogan called incoming chief Andrew Matturro PoliceMatturoa man of vision, confidence, character and compassion. These wise words Brogan had for his replacement came in the form of an Abraham Lincoln speech he quoted on the day of his own initiation. "If I were to try to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for any other business." He explained that this was the ideal he kept in mind when times got tough. To him the quote meant that though everyone has their own point of view on his work and choices, the most important thing is to work hard and do the right thing, regardless of people's complaints. Matturro will surely benefit from this advice in the years to come.

Newly-installed Chief Matturro's initiation speech was equally as grateful and heartwarming. He started out by expressing gratitude to Mayor Steves, the entire Board of Trustees, Village Manager Alfred Gatta and Deputy Village Manager Steven Pappalardo for their confidence and trust in him to lead the department. He also thanked his wife and children for their support over the years. He gave credit to Scarsdale Village workers and officials of all kinds, noting that he would not be where he is today without the help of any of them.

He did have some concerns upon being named the new Chief--as many of us probably would! Soon after hearing the good news, he called former Scarsdale Police Chief Ferraro to thank him for the opportunity. He told him that he and Chief Brogan had left him with such an excellent and capable department, and wondered where he should go from here. Ferraro ensured him that there "is always room for improvement, and you can always move an organization forward", and reassured him that he would do a fine job.

policeceremonycrowdThe new Chief then went on to highlight the stellar job Brogan did as Chief in his 12 years. Echoing Brogan's goal to leave the department in a better state than he found it., he said,"Chief Brogan", Matturro said, "you achieved more than your goal." He noted that, though Brogan was dedicated and driven himself, he always looked out for others and pushed his officers to their limits. He thanked Brogan for his guidance, and explained that he will strive to be the kind of strong, yet caring leader, that Brogan was to this department.

Finally, Matturro had some wonderful words to share about the Scarsdale police officers. He explained that although many of them have impressive degrees that can be applied to many different fields and types of work, the one thing they have in common is that "each of them decided at some point that they would dedicate their professional lives to serving others." Though many of the officers do not live in Scarsdale, the passion and pride with which they fulfill their duties would make anyone believe they are residents. Noting that all eyes have been on the police (from Ferguson to New York City.) Matturro vowed that Scarsdale force would continue to serve justly and professionally—treating residents in the same manner they'd want their own families to be treated.

Matturro said that thought he is not usually one to brag about rank or achievements, he is extremely proud and honored to be named Chief of such an incredible department in an incredible community.

Also at the ceremony, five officers were promoted by the Scarsdale Police Department. Here is some information about each one:

Captain Thomas Altizio

Thomas Altizio joined the force in 1986, and has been PoliceAltizioinstrumental in organizing and maintaining the departments many Information and Technology systems. He has supervised many successful investigations and has done an exemplary job in advancing the efficiency of the Investigation Section. He has been promoted to the Rank of Captain.

 

Detective Lieutenant Ed Murphy

policedmuprhyLt. Murphy began his career in 1990 with the Mount Vernon Police Department before joining the SPD. He served as a Field Training Officer, Patrol and Special Operations Sergeant and is currently the Commanding Officer of the Patrol Section--the largest one in the department. The Patrol section met 10 out of its 10 goals in 2014, which is a testament to Murphy's outstanding job and leadership. He has been promoted to Detective Lieutenant.

 

Lieutenant Joseph DuSavage

Sgt. DuSavage entered the dusavageforce with the Putnam Valley Police Department in 1994 before joining the SPD. He is involved in many aspects of training, and has served as a Field Training Officer, Department Armorer, Head Firearms Instructor, Patrol Sergeant, and is currently the Special Operations Sergeant. He is being promoted to the Rank of Lieutenant.

 

Detective Sargeant James Newman

newmanSargeant Newman joined the Scarsdale force in 1997. He has been instrumental in the department's successful maintenance of its National and State Accreditation Programs and is involved in many aspects of training. He has served as a Field Training Officer and General Topics Instructor as well. He is currently assigned as the Accreditation/Training and Scheduling Sergeant. He was described by Matturro as a "jack of all trades", who always does what he is assigned without even a word in opposition. He is being promoted to Detective Sergeant.

Sargeant David Rosa

Rosa joined the Scarsdale Police Department Policerosain 2006 after serving with the New York City Police Department for 6 years. He is a certified bicycle officer, Field Training Officer, and is currently working in the Patrol Section. David is known as a knowledgeable senior police officer who is always willing to assist new officers as they learn and acclimate to their new positions. He is being promoted to Rank of Sergeant.

Photos by Jon Thaler - see more and purchase copies here.

algattaScarsdale Village Manager Al Gatta has announced that he plans to retire this coming June. Gatta has run the Village for as long as most can remember, managing many major infrastructure improvements and a professional staff who some say are among the best in the county. We spoke to Gatta about his time in Scarsdale and why he plans to step down this year. Here is what he shared:

How long have you worked in Scarsdale and where did you work before?

I have been in Scarsdale for twenty years and before that I was City Manager in Hartford, CT; Ann Arbor, MI and Methuen, MA and held management jobs in New Jersey.

What do you plan to do when you retire?

I am looking to do more policy work which means housing, employment, regional approaches to services, funding schools, income maintenance, transportation and how best to fund local governments. I may also teach a class or two which I did at Trinity College in Hartford and University of Michigan in Ann Arbor.

Why did you decide to retire now?

It is time to move on. Any good organization has to have movement at the top to bring in new perspectives and approaches to addressing challenges. We have done a lot of employee training and education and have made the organization one of the better ones in the County;

What are you proud of?

Twenty years is a good run and I was the first educated and trained professional manager in Scarsdale and brought management improvements to the finance system, budgeting, decision-making process and line services. Former managers followed the old pattern of either being a trained engineer or attorney to serve as managers.

I managed many capital projects over the years such as downtown traffic, parking, pedestrian improvements, sidewalks; the Christie Place Development and parking facility; the new Popham Road Bridge; the new Public Safety Building; pool improvements; new athletic fields including one artificial turf field at the High School; Kids Base program and long term lease; restrooms and tennis building at the high school and new restrooms and a tennis building at Brite Avenue. We closed the compost facility at Crossway and built the leaf transfer station at the same location, renovated the Supply Field Building, completed major multi-million stormwater projects and renovated all 16 village playgrounds. What else? We did a rehab of the Scarsdale Railroad Station; a land lease with SVAC; multimillion renovations to the Ardsley Road and Reeves Newsome Water Pumping Stations, initiated the rehabilitation of the Fire Station #1 and the rehabilitation of Wayside Cottage.

What were some of the biggest challenges you faced?

The challenges all involved being part of and managing a non-political system that made decisions by trying to achieve consensus. It takes patience, understanding, tolerance and faith. There were no shortcuts or decisions made easy because of the political votes. It's a very good structure for local governments.

What were some of the most controversial issues during your tenure here?

Controversial issues are always budget, taxes and particular land use issues as illustrated by the constant tension between the need to change and the limited growth theory. Also the interference of the State government in the management of local affairs, particularly budgeting and taxation by ranking bureaucrats who have no local government experience but do have great political acumen.

Who were some of the more "colorful" residents you encountered?

There have been a few and I have always taken it in stride. Looking for the humor in most instances is the only way I have survived for 45 years.

Who did you enjoy working with?

I have been fortunate in having had the best elected officials anyone can hope to work with as a local government manager. The elected officials have been smart, educated, sensitive, caring, wanting to do the right thing for the community honest, and nonpolitical. Also the Village employees and Department Heads have been among the most trained and educated I have worked with over the decades and compared to other local government workers in the county are head and shoulders over their performance.

What will be your legacy to Scarsdale?

I am not interested in a legacy; after all I am not the president of the United States and one thing I am very proud of is that I never took myself and position too seriously. The quality of work and honesty and straight talk was always a desire of my wanting to do my job as well as possible. I never tried too "out slick" anyone and those that did it to me drew my disdain.

In an email to Village staff announcing his retirement, Gatta said, It has been a pleasure towork with all of you during the last two decades as there is no way any manager can be successful without a loyal hard working workforce."

newsScarsdalians made headlines this week for reasons good and bad. Here are four of your neighbors in the news:

SHS Alumni Zachary Seward, age 29, married Kate Laurie Lee at the Liberty Warehouse in Brooklyn on New Year's Eve. While attending SHS, Seward was a champion debater who later went on to Harvard where he was the managing editor for the Harvard Crimson. At Harvard, Seward co-wrote a story for the Wall Street Journal breaking the news that President Larry Summer would resign. He is now the product director and senior editor at Quartz, a business news website owned by Atlantic Media. His parents still live in Scarsdale where his dad, Stephen Seward serves as the executive director of the Scarsdale Schools Education Foundation which is now raising money to support a new design lab and fitness center at Scarsdale High School.

Rob Fishman, a 2004 graduate of SHS was named to the Forbes Magazine 4th annual list RobFishmanof "30 under 30" millenials who the magazine calls "young game changers, movers and makers." Fishman is a co-founder of Niche, a network of more than 5,000 creators across 16 social-media networks such as Instagram, Snapchat, Vine and Tumblr, in 2013. Has an ongoing relationship with Hewlett-Packard, which began after an initial Vine campaign collaboration became a nationally aired TV spot consisting solely of Vines. In its first year, Niche grew to 34 employees with $9 million in revenue. While at SHS Fishman was also a top debater and editor of the Maroon. Before forming Niche, he worked as the Social Media Editor of the Huffington Post. (Full disclosure, Fishman is the son of the founder of Scarsdale10583.com.)

Last, In February, HBO will air a six-part documentary about an infamous Scarsdale man, Robert Durst, who is a suspect in the murder of his wife Kathie in 1982, the killing of friend Susan Berman in 2000 and the dismemberment of a merchant seaman in 2001. Durst grew up in Scarsdale, one of four children of real estate magnate Seymour Durst and his wife Bernice. It is reported that at the age of 7 Durst witnessed his mother's suicide when she jumped or fell off the roof of the family's home. A NY Times article from 2001 says that Bernice "became disoriented by an overdose of medication for asthma and fell from a rain-slick roof -- but family members acknowledged that Bernice had committed suicide." We have been unable to find out the address of the Durst's family home in Scarsdale, but if you know the location, please share it in the comments section below.

durstThe HBO series, called "The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst" is based on nearly 10 years of research by the filmmakers who reviewed documents and conducted more than 100 interviews with friends, investigators, journalists, lawyers and relatives. The film was made with Durst's cooperation and includes more than 25 hours of interviews with him.

Durst, now 71, lives in Texas and owns a townhouse in Harlem, In 2006 he was awarded $65 million in a settlement of a lawsuit over his share of the family fortune.

veteranThe issue of the Alternative Veterans' Tax Exemption was revisited at the Board of Education (BOE) business meeting on January 12, 2015.

To recap, Governor Cuomo enacted legislation in December 2013 that would allow (but not require) school districts to provide tax relief to qualified veterans. Veterans already receive partial exemptions for Village and County taxes, and this new legislation provides an additional avenue for exemptions. The law provides a benefit for qualifying veterans and their surviving spouses by reducing their taxable assessments – and therefore their property taxes. As of April 2014, there were 305 veterans in Scarsdale receiving various levels of exemptions.

In April 2014 the BOE discussed this issue at a business meeting. Ultimately, the Board voted against the exemption by 5-1 based on the fact that information about the implications to the other taxpayers were unclear partially because Scarsdale was in the midst of a property valuation reassessment. The burden of the exempted amount (at the time estimated to be $558,358 at the highest level of exemption) would not be funded through the state or federal government but would be shared among the balance of Scarsdale taxpayers. The legislation required the resolution to adopt the exemption to be passed by May 1, 2014 (along with a required public hearing) so there was little time to gather additional financial information or hear from the general public on the issue. Many veterans spoke at that meeting and were extremely disappointed that the BOE voted to take no action on the matter.

Fast forward to January 2015 when the BOE feels more confident about the timing and its ability to gather information. The Board was in agreement last night that it should move forward with the first step of providing the basic exemption level for qualified veterans. Once a resolution that a basic level of tax exemption is enacted, the Board may decide to increase or decrease the exemption level based on specific guidelines set forth in the legislation. The decision to increase or decrease the exemption amount is required to be made under a separate resolution and after a public hearing. The plan right now is that a resolution on the basic exemption will be available for discussion at the next BOE meeting on January 26, 2015 and will be voted on at the February 9, 2015 meeting along with the required public hearing. The Board has asked for more information from the Scarsdale Tax Assessor to be available for the January 26 meeting in order to fully understand the numbers involved.

During the public comment period, the BOE heard from two long-term resident veterans. Mr. Martin Molot of Lincoln Road wanted to make sure that as the BOE weighed the additional tax burden to non-veterans it took into account the fact that the overall tax base in Scarsdale is increasing as a result of the large amount of new construction.

Mr. Newton Schiller of Lee Road said he attended the meeting to make sure that the BOE took action on this item and thanked the Board for making decision to move forward.

Community members are urged to view this portion of the meeting on the BOE video on demand site as well as to review the supporting materials available with the January 12, 2015 meeting agenda and come to the next BOE meeting with questions and comments.

Top10I am often asked about the top stories on Scarsdale10583. Readers want to know what content gets the highest number of hits and resonates most with readers. Now that we've come to the end of 2014 I thought I would share the greatest hits of 2014 with you as measured by our site analytics.

Some will seem quite obvious – but others are more curious:

1) Tax Revaluation

The coverage of the tax revaluation was a big hit on Scarsdale10583. Real estate tax appraisals are top-of-mind for Scarsdale homeowners and many were eager to know how their home was appraised, what their new tax rate would be --- and most important, how their tax bills compare with that of their neighbors. The first Village-wide revaluation in 49 years caused much discussion and debate, sometimes escalating to heated shouting matches. Especially popular was an eloquent complaint from notable Scarsdale residents Seymour and Audrey Topping about the injustice of raising the tax bill for their home on 2 acres in the Heathcote Association. They currently pay $45,000 per year, but with their new assessment of $4+ million, they stand to see an increase in their tax bill. They are not alone in their discontent and hundreds of appeals are now before a judicial administrator so there will be more coverage to come.

2) Vaping

What exactly is vaping and why should you care? Vaping or smoking hookah pens is a new trend among teens. These slick, flavorful e-cigarettes are nicotine-free and tar-free and marketed as safe cigarettes. But are they safe? Read what the controversy is all about.

3) Massa Closes

Massa will go down in history as the last restaurant to occupy the former MassaLogosite of the historic Heathcote Tavern. Ever since Scarsdale lost the tavern, the fate of the building has been in question. Bistro Citron made a go of it for a few years, and when they closed their doors Massa filled the void. Popular for a time, it also lost its way while the owners of the building were engaged in the lengthy process of getting permission to convert the site to initially 11 and now 14 residential units. Though the façade of the tavern will be preserved, that's about all that will remain of this iconic building.

4) Earl Graves Home Goes Down

8HeathcoteConstructionWhen Earl Graves agreed to sell his brick mansion at 8 Heathcote Road, the new owners asked for permission to raze it. They claimed that the house was a warren of small rooms, poorly constructed and difficult to renovate. However, the application to tear down the house put the Village's Historic Preservation laws to the test. After all, the preservation laws instructed the Committee on Historic Preservation to determine if the "building is related to an historically important individual." Clearly Graves, the founder of Black Enterprise Magazine, was important so the CHP denied the demolition request. The buyers appealed that decision to the BAR who turned them down initially but ultimately voted to permit them to tear everything down but the brick façade of the central portion of the house. That is all you will see today if you drive down Heathcote Road. A single wall of bricks. Check it out.

5) More Closings

In February of 2014, the popular Golden Horseshoe restaurant Katzenberg's disappeared overnight. Management didn't even mention their plans to their employees who showed up for work the following morning only to find the doors locked. This is the second time that Katzenbergs has opened and closed in the same shopping center. Puzzling indeed.

childsplayAlso popular with readers was the more recent news that both Taiim Middle Eastern Wine Cellar and toy store Scarsdale Children's Play were closing.

As much as readers wanted to know what closed, they were also interested in what was opening. Two new restaurants appeared on the local scene and were enthusiastically greeted by Scarsdale10583 readers. The Spadaro family who made their name in New Rochelle, has now opened an italian eatery on Central Avenue and enthusiasts of Greek food will be pleased to find Petra, a new Greek restaurant on Garth Road.

6) Prom Photospromax

Always popular with readers are the photo galleries from the pre-prom red carpet events preceding the Scarsdale Prom. The parade of seniors all decked out for the prom rivaled Hollywood celebrities at the Emmy's. Check out this year's stars of the senior class.

7) Don't Ask Don't Tell

Questions Not to Ask or Answer in Scarsdale got lots of attention on the site. Most of the questions involve the kids – from tots, to teens to grads. Read this so that you don't insert foot in mouth. 

8) Hora Time

Bar and Bat Mitzvahs Scarsdale Style: These life cycle events are a focal bat-mitzvah-girlpoint of a Scarsdale childhood. So many variables, so many decisions, so much money! This article reviewed it all. Where to have it, who to hire, how to entertain your guests and imbue the day with meaning as well.

9) Police Report and 10) Real Estate

We can't complete this article without mentioning the Police Blotter and the weekly Real Estate column... perennial favorites on Scarsdale10583. Petty crimes, family disagreements, mishaps and stunts provide great fodder for comment. House sales and stories and the constantly shifting real estate market all make for lively reading too.

Thanks to all of you for sharing your Scarsdale experiences with us on your community website, Scarsdale10583.com. Continue to send your stories to scarsdalecomments@gmail.com and together we'll make 2015 another great year in the 'dale.

Leave a Comment

Share on Myspace