Scarsdale Librarian Helps Select Prestigious Literary Award Winners

Ever wondered how children’s books earn those prestigious literary medals like the Newbery and Caldecott? Behind every award-winning title stands a dedicated team of literary professionals who carefully evaluate and champion stories that inspire young readers for generations to come.

Among them is Sarah Rodriguez, a respected children's collection development librarian at Scarsdale Public Library, who has dedicated her career to serving the Scarsdale community for 13 years. This year, Sarah played a pivotal role in selecting the winners of the John Newbery Medal, one of the most esteemed honors in children’s literature. This is not Sarah’s first contribution to children’s literature, over the past 5 years, she has also served on the Caldecott and Stonewall committees.

Award selection is an intensive process. As a committee member, Sarah read and meticulously evaluated hundreds of books, collaborating with fifteen fellow librarians to determine the most exceptional literary contributions for young readers. The Newbery Medal, awarded annually, considers books that enhance children’s understanding, abilities, and appreciation for literature from birth up to age 14.

In a letter written to Library Director Beth Bermel, Maeve Visser Knoth, Chair of the 2025 John Newbery Award Selection Committee, said, “Sarah made major contributions to our work. She had so many insightful things to say and, I am sure, brought back new skills to the workplace. I loved getting to know her and working with her - you are lucky to have such a committed, thoughtful, enthusiastic colleague.”

Announced on January 27 during the Youth Media Awards, these prestigious accolades recognize the most distinguished American children’s books published in the previous year. The official award presentation will take place in June at the American Library Association (ALA) Annual Conference.Sarah Rodriguez

Of this experience, Sarah had this to say, “Serving on the Newbery selection committee deepened not just my knowledge of children's literature, but my understanding of how different books speak to different readers. With fifteen professionals from across the country on the committee, each of us saw the same book in fifteen different ways, and each of those perspectives enriched our understanding of what makes a book truly distinguished. Every time a family comes to the library seeking their child's next great read, I draw on this experience. It’s a reminder that the perfect book for each child isn't the one we as adults personally love most, but the one that will spark their own unique journey as a reader.”

The ALA, a leading voice for libraries across the country, is committed to advocating for quality library services and ensuring public access to information. The Association for Library Service to Children (ALSC)—the world’s largest organization dedicated to children’s library services—plays a key role in assessing literary materials, expanding access to library programs, and supporting the professional development of librarians like Sarah.

As an advocate for literacy and lifelong learning, Sarah’s participation in this prestigious award process highlights the Scarsdale Public Library’s dedication to bringing the best in children’s literature to the community. Families, educators, and young readers alike can explore these award-winning titles at the library and discover stories that shape young minds for the future.

Library Director Beth Bermel expressed her gratitude, saying, “Congratulations, Sarah, and thank you for all your hard work. As someone who actively sought out books with the Newbery label on the cover as a kid, this means a lot to me personally as well.”

For more information on the latest award-winning books or to learn more about Scarsdale Public Library’s children’s programs click here.