Committee Denies Application to Raze Milstein Family Home at 76 Birchall Drive
- Category: Real Estate
- Published: Wednesday, 21 September 2022 16:51
- Joanne Wallenstein
Lawyers for the Milstein family made a third attempt to gain approval to raze a family home at 76 Birchall Drive at a meeting of the Committee for Historic Preservation on September 20, 2022.
Based on convincing evidence that the house was the work of master architect Simon B. Zelnik, the committee reluctantly turned down the application to demolish it. Though the vote was three in favor of the demolition and two against it the code requires four votes in favor and that night, two of the committee members were not present.
The proceedings were further complicated by a last minute change from a virtual meeting to a hybrid meeting that was not noted on the Village website. Consequently the committee was present at Village Hall, along with the applicants. But neighbors, who had formed a group to save the house, were not advised that the meeting would be held in person.
The original mid-century modern house was built in 1950 and sits on three acres with a circular driveway lined with Japanese maples. The home was designed by architect Simon B. Zelnik who also designed two other homes in Scarsdale, which have both been destroyed, along with the Joyce Theater, the Riverdale Temple and the Chemical Bank Building in NY.
One of the criteria for the preservation of a home is a finding that it is the work of a master, so much of the discussion centered on Zelnik’s credentials. At the prior meeting, Chair Adam Lindenbaum asked the neighbors to bring evidence that Zelnik could indeed be defined as a master, which they did with the help of Bryan Zelnik, an architect and grandson of Simon B. Zelnik.
Exhibits presented to the committee shows that Simon B. Zelnik was named a fellow of the American Institute of Architect in 1967, when he was awarded a certificate, a medal and a ceremonial dinner plate. This honor is awarded to only 3% of AIA members. His submission included the homes he built in Scarsdale.
Representatives for the Milstein’s retained architectural historian Emily Cooperman from Cherry Hill, New Jersey to present evidence that the home did not warrant preservation.
She sought to prove that Zelnik was not a master, as he lacked “greatness,” and to show that renovations to the house and the roofline altered Zelnik’s design. After outlining changes and additions she argued, “It is not the form that Simon Zelnik built.”
The Milstein’s case was bolstered by Andrew Dolkart, the Village’s expert who reviewed the home and found, “76 Birchall is a rare example of a mid-century Modern house in Scarsdale and it has some very handsome features, notably the massing and stonework of the front elevation. I think that an argument could be made for the house and the grounds for rarity, but, in general it does not appear to meet the criteria for preservation. Simon Zelnik was not a master architect. The house was commissioned by a significant individual, but he does not seem to have lived in the house for very long. The house has had some significant alterations that compromise the integrity of the design, notably at the rear.”
Another expert brought in by the Milstein’s was Barry Silberstang who reviewed the alterations made to the house, primarily to the rear, to demonstrate that the house was no longer what it was. Discussing the changes, he said, “To a layman it may not matter. To an architect it is huge. It is mediocre.”
He disparaged Zelnik and his credentials, saying “I went to Cooper Union and I never heard of him. It is not a significant house any longer. …Get old enough you will receive honorariums.” He conceded that he was not an AIA fellow.
Neighbor David Greenberger of 65 Birchall was a late arrival to the meeting. He said, “I was moved that Zelnik was profiled in the Architectural Forum. I think Bryan Zelnik gave a persuasive argument …..The residents of Birchall Drive and Mr. Zelnik have given you much evidence. His submission to the AIA was based on the houses he built in Scarsdale.”
Gayle Hellman of 62 Birchall Drive said, “You asked team Birchall to come through with the evidence – and we did. About the additions, from what I see in Scarsdale, changes are allowed to homes that are considered historic. According to the way Emily Cooperman defined a master previously, Zelnik is a master. He is a fellow of the AIA and did enter competitions in NYC.”
Later at the meeting, Hellman pointed out an inconsistency in Cooperman’s testimony. Hellman noted that Cooperman had previously said architect Julius Gregory was not a master because he was not a fellow of the AIA and did not have articles in professional publication, but argued now that Zelnik was not a master though he held those credentials.
Calling in on Zoom, Bryan Zelnik countered, “I find it upsetting how you disparaged by grandfather. IM Pei and Philip Johnson were both fellow in the same class of the AIA. When he designed the first Baracini house my grandfather was the grandfather of modern architecture in Scarsdale. The only modern architecture magazine featured his home. I presented overwhelming evidence of my grandfather’s contribution to architecture in Scarsdale and architectural history.”
Committee members spoke.
Chair Adam Lindenbaum read a statement from Committee member and architect Mark Behr who was not present at the meeting. He said, “We did not have all the pertinent information at the first meeting. Now I consider Zelnik a master in his field …. Due to his inclusion as a fellow in the AIA, two of the six works submitted were residences in Scarsdale – those two are both gone at this point…. 76 Birchall is the last remaining residence which makes it more unique and historic. Though it took three times to get admitted (to the AIA), that does not decrease the accomplishment… The additions and renovations did not diminish the design and characteristics of the original design. For the reasons stated above I cannot support the application.”
Jonathan Lerner said, “I work in real estate, I look at houses every day. I went up the driveway today. It blends into the landscape. It is not a cookie cutter home. It is unique. It is a beautiful home. When you go to see a piece of art and it moves you.”
Talaiya Safdar said, We have evidence for criteria 3 or 4. (Zelnik was a master or “That the building embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction that possess high artistic value;”
Kevin Reed thought there was enough evidence to deny the application and let the Board of Trustees decide, if the applicants appealed.
Wendy Goldstein was concerned about the renovations to the house. She said, “Assuming he is a master, how substantive are the changes and do they make it not a Zelnik house?”
Lerner responded, “Look at the house – it’s the same house as it was in 1950. You can’t see the changes in the roof.”
Lindenbaum said, “We have to speak clearly and we have to make a recommendation. I need to be convinced that the changes did not affect the historical significance of the house.”
Kevin Reed then changed his mind, saying, “We’re here to preserve homes, but only if they meet certain criteria – I am going to support the application. Due to the renovations.”
Taliaiya Safdar defended preservation, saying “What home is worth preserving if not this?”
Ultimately, Chair Adam Lindenbaum, Kevin Reed and Wendy Goldstein cast their three votes to approve the demolition of the house. Talaiya Safdar and Jonathan Lerner voted to deny the application. The vote stood 3-2. Lindenbaum reviewed the code and found that four votes were needed to approve an application. Short one vote, the application was denied.
Lindenbaum told the applicants they had the right to appeal to the Board of Trustees and to plead hardship.
The decision could be appealed on hardship, but the question arises: Is it a hardship when one of the wealthiest families in the country is denied the right to demolish a home and sell the property to a developer who will subdivide the property and build two homes where there are now one? Rather than sell it to a developer, could they find a family who might live in the home and treasure it, even if the sale price is a bit lower?
And about the resolve of the CHP: The committee had ample evidence to defend Zelnik as a master architect and to defend a rare mid-century modern home in Scarsdale. However, it was clear that the leadership of the committee was reluctant to turn them down and spur a potential lawsuit from the applicants who opened the meeting by threatening an Article 78.
Ever since the entire Committee for Historic Preservation (CHP) resigned in protest in 2017 when the Village board overturned their decision on 12 Dolma Road, the replacement committee seems wary about following the code to preserve homes, especially when the owners have deep pockets.
If any homes are to be saved, the code needs to be strengthened, the Village Board needs to exercise some resolve or new personnel are needed on the CHP.
20 Kensington Road
20 Kensington Road sits on a streets in a prime location in Scarsdale. This Fox Meadow home has .51 acres, stone walls, patio for entertaining and a putting green for family fun. Over 5700 interior square feet not including the lower level. This Tudor has been updated over the years including a layout with open kitchen/family room/dining room for easy everyday living. A library and sunroom offer additional office space very separate from the hub of activity. Master bedroom with three closets and master bathroom suite: two sinks, separate tub and shower and dressing area. Five additional bedrooms with three bathrooms. Third floor has three rooms with bathroom. Garage off the mudroom and two powder rooms on first floor. A main and back staircase. High end kitchen appliances, 5-zones heat and 4-zones central air. Electronic gate. Generator. Patio has a gas grill - so ready to host a BBQ!
Sale Price: $2,850,000
Real Estate Taxes: $66,058
Assessed Value: $2,575,000
83 Carthage Road
Heathcote Colonial set in a convenient location. Gracious thru entrance hall, living room, dining room with built-in cabinetry, kitchen with center island/new countertops and backsplash, dishwasher, microwave and oven, door to patio and back garden, family room with fireplace, powder room, mudroom, attached two car garage. Upstairs: primary bedroom with two closets, dressing room, en-suite spa bath with tub and separate stall shower and dual sinks plus three additional bedrooms and hall bath. Lower level offers a recreation room, home office, laundry room and space plus full bath. A truly special place to call home!
Sale Price: $1,950,000
Real Estate Taxes: $34,143
Assessed Value: $1,350,000
45 Seely Place
Arts & Crafts Colonial set on a half acre of flat, property in Edgemont School District. This 4 Bedroom, 3.1 Bath home features 2-story EH & an floor plan. 9 ft ceilings on 1st Fl plus a multitude of windows across the home. Millwork & architectural details abound. 1st Fl features ceilings, Living Rm w/beamed ceiling & stone FPL, Kitchen w/Butler's Pantry & adjacent Family Rm, Dining Rm, 2 Home Offices & Powder Rm. 2nd fl has a Primary Bedrm w/WIC & Bath, 3 add'l Bedrooms, hall Bath & Laundry closet. Walkout Lower Level has a Mudroom area, Bathroom, open area & storage. Rear deck & covered stone porch are for large entertaining or quiet repose. 560 SF loft area over 2-car garage offers endless possibilities.
Sale Price: $1,550,000
Real Estate Taxes: $45,023
Assessed Value: $1,214,100
4 Brookfield Lane, Scarsdale
5 Bedrooms, 6.2 Bathrooms, 7,618 Square Feet
Welcome home to this not to be missed 7,618 square foot sprawling Contemporary Ranch. Set on over 1 acre of lush, newly landscaped, park-like private property with pool, outdoor patio and built-in professional BBQ adjoined by a screened-in porch off the kitchen and sunroom off the family room. This home is filled with light and high ceilings for incredible entertaining flow and family functionality. Extensive renovations include: new roof, skylights, exterior brick, driveway, LED lighting, air handlers, boiler, generator, powder room, bathroom and more. Extensive landscaping including 200 arborvitae trees planted around the entire perimeter of the home for privacy along with magnificent specimen plantings. Don't miss this one of a kind special opportunity!
Click here for more information
Sale price: $5,495,000
181 Secor Road, Scarsdale
4 Bedrooms, 3.1 Bathrooms, 2,614 Square Feet
Sunny Quaker Ridge Colonial offers a renovated interior, a large master suite addition and one of the prettiest backyards in Scarsdale! Step inside this delightful property and instantly feel "at home". Warm hardwood floors, well equipped and spacious kitchen with adjoining family room, stylish powder room, large living area with wood burning fireplace and door to a spacious bluestone patio with seating wall and automatic awning, plus golf course views from many second floor windows make this home a winner! The master suite addition adds a certain comfort with it's vaulted ceiling, two large walk-in closets and luxurious bath with natural stone shower floor. Three more bedrooms and two full baths provide ample space for all and complete the second floor. Whether you are zooming for work or school, lounging on the back patio under the shade of the awning, playing soccer or tag in your large, private backyard or once again commuting to the city for work, this home is the perfect fit!
Click here for more information
Sale price: $1,175,000