Proposal to Build Ten Homes on Kol Ami Property Could Impact Downstream Neighbors in Scarsdale
- Thursday, 19 November 2026 08:24
- Last Updated: Thursday, 19 November 2026 08:29
- Published: Thursday, 19 November 2026 08:24
- Joanne Wallenstein
- Hits: 120
Proposal for a 10 home subdivision on Soundview Avenue.The threat of even more water draining into Scarsdale is looming due to a proposal from Congregation Kol Ami to develop land adjacent to Cushman Road.
At a Planning Board meeting for the city of White Plains on October 20, 2026, lawyers for the synagogue, located at 252 Soundview Avenue, proposed plans for 10 home subdivision on an 8.5 acre plot adjacent to Congregation Kol Ami. Plans were first presented at the April, 2026 meeting of the Planning Board. See background here.
The homes would be accessed by a road running from Soundview Avenue, extending across the property to Cushman Road in Scarsdale, or end in a cul de sac in the development. If the property were subdivided, the synagogue would retain 12.3 acres.
The property abuts an area that has been the subject of significant flooding for years. A watershed at the junction of Cushman, Willow and Sheldrake Roads in Scarsdale collects runoff from 118 acres, including parts of White Plains. The Village of Scarsdale has been considering plans to improve the drainage system in that area for years, but to date has not moved forward with the work.
So, though the proposed homes are in White Plains, the development could impact downstream neighbors in Scarsdale.
Helen Maccarino lives on Cushman Road in Scarsdale and has been following stormwater issues for years. She attended the White Plains Planning Board hearing. Here is her report:
I attended a public hearing regarding a proposed 10-house subdivision on the Congregation Kol Ami property adjacent to Scarsdale. The hearing was standing room only. No Scarsdale residents were advised of this hearing.
The concerns expressed at the hearing were primarily about flooding risks, stormwater management systems, environmental damage, and increases in traffic. The same issues we here in Scarsdale grapple with too. The proximity of this subdivision to Scarsdale makes us especially vulnerable.
- Stormwater Management & Drainage: The plan includes a detention pond to handle runoff, directing water across the property into the Fenway Golf Club pond. Maintenance of the entire drainage system will fall to a 10-home HOA, but compliance monitoring remains unclear. (Red flag!). Homeowners along Milford Drive already struggle with drainage problems and were leery about the impact the subdivision will have. Scarsdale will also be at risk should failure of any part of the system occur. Fenway Golf Club 's attorney attended and commented about the short window they had to review the proposal and their concerns about the maintenance of the system and about the runoff volume and velocity that they will have to manage.
- Environmental Impact: Site clearing will remove extensive old-growth trees and their root system and the leaf canopy that all contribute to helping mitigate runoff. Loss of most of the woodlands will also eliminate the wildlife habitat. A portion of the woodlands along the Cushman Road side of the site will remain as a buffer zone.
- Traffic: Concerns were raised regarding additional traffic on Soundview Avenue and whether the currently blocked driveway on Cushman Road will be reopened, which could affect local traffic flow.
The project is currently in the preliminary stage. The presenter was from a site plan consultant firm hired by Kol Ami. Residents and attendees at the recent public hearing have requested that the Planning Board extend the hearings until these drainage, environmental, and traffic concerns are fully addressed.
Public involvement at hearings are critical. Neighbors can impact what happens in their neighborhood. It's never too late to speak up.
