Thursday, Nov 19th

Scarsdale BOE Hears Calls for More School Staff Amid Growing Budget Pressures

FMSchoolGardenThe Scarsdale Board of Education met on November 16 to begin planning the 2027-28 school budget, review the district's long-term financial outlook and discuss the findings of an internal payroll audit.

During a public budget forum, parents and community representatives urged the district to restore teacher aide hours, expand elementary social worker support and strengthen special education programming. These requests came as district officials warned that rising expenses and limits on property tax increases continue to put pressure on Scarsdale's finances.

The meeting also included updates on the district's $101 million capital bond, school lunch operations and the transition to electric school buses.

Parents Call for More Social Workers and Teacher Aides

The public budget forum drew representatives from the Parent Teacher Council (PTC), individual school PTAs and the League of Women Voters of Scarsdale, along with several residents.

Jenny Simon Tabak, speaking on behalf of the PTC Budget Study Committee, urged the Board to reconsider several staffing requests that were removed from last year's budget, including additional elementary social workers, teacher aides, an expansion of the middle school's Integrated Co-Teaching (ICT) program and another high school math teacher.

Simon Tabak acknowledged the difficult decisions facing the district but emphasized the importance of maintaining Scarsdale's educational priorities. "We are asking you to keep students front and center when you are making the tough budget decisions," she said. Read her comments here.

Teacher aide staffing was another major concern. Last year's budget included a $250,000 reduction in proposed teacher aide funding, which parents said has affected classroom support, lunch and recess supervision, and teachers' workloads.

Heathcote PTA President Sean McDevitt reported that two first-grade classrooms at his school currently receive no teacher aide hours during the week. He encouraged the district to establish a minimum level of aide support across classrooms, rather than leaving some without any additional assistance.

McDevitt also highlighted the limited availability of social workers, explaining that Heathcote's more than 350 students have access to a school social worker for only two days of each six-day cycle.

"Some students face a delay in getting support with a personal or family issue that requires immediate attention," he said.

Greenacres PTA Budget Chair Peng Wu raised similar concerns about staffing and student well-being. Wu explained that school psychologists are increasingly occupied with evaluations and administrative responsibilities, leaving little time for preventive support.

"There was a time when school psychologists could proactively run social skills groups and lead social emotional well-being lessons," Wu said. "Today in Greenacre, that proactive support is nearly impossible."

At the middle school, parents requested that ICT classes, currently offered in sixth grade, be expanded to at least seventh grade. They argued that continuing the program would provide more appropriate learning environments for students who benefit from integrated general and special education instruction.

At Scarsdale High School, the PTA expressed concerns about class sizes and access to electives. The committee specifically noted that Physics 513 currently has three sections of 30 students and urged the district to maintain reasonable class sizes while preserving the variety of courses available to students.

District Faces Difficult Budget Decisions

Superintendent Drew Patrick and Assistant Superintendent for Business Andrew Lennon outlined the financial challenges facing the district as it begins developing next year's budget.

Patrick explained that the current $197.1 million budget required approximately $1.9 million in expenditure reductions, including deferred staffing additions and cuts to operational and technology expenses.

"Because roughly 80% of the budget goes toward compensation, these reductions inevitably impacted personnel," Patrick said, noting that the district has attempted to handle position eliminations through attrition rather than layoffs.

The district's long-range financial plan projects continued deficits as expenses grow faster than available revenue.

Lennon reported that the district's financial outlook has improved somewhat since last year, largely because of lower-than-anticipated spending and difficult decisions made during the previous budget process. However, the revised projections still show that continued reliance on reserves could exhaust the district's available fund balance by the 2030-31 fiscal year if no changes are made.
FundBalanceForecastThe district ended the 2025-26 fiscal year with approximately $20.6 million in total fund balance, down from $22.1 million the previous year.

Lennon emphasized that the projections illustrate the risks of continued deficit spending rather than a recommendation to deplete reserves.

"We want to seek to restore rather than deplete fund balance and reserves," he said.

Board members discussed evaluating alternative financial scenarios, including reducing spending or increasing revenue beyond what would be permitted under the state's property tax cap.

KeyTakeaways

The tax cap was also a major topic during the public forum. Former Board President Jeff Blatt encouraged the Board not to make staying under the cap its primary objective.

"This district cannot continue excellence with 2% or less budgets every year," Blatt said, arguing that maintaining the quality of Scarsdale's schools should take precedence over a strict commitment to the cap.

Speaking for the League of Women Voters, Dalya Kahn also raised concerns about the district's continued reliance on reserves and encouraged greater flexibility in the budget calendar to allow community organizations more time to review proposals. Read her comments here.

The Board is scheduled to adopt the 2027-28 budget on April 12, with the public vote set for May 18.

Internal Audit Identifies Payroll Issues

Earlier in the evening, the Board convened as the district's audit committee to review an internal audit of payroll procedures.

The audit identified several areas needing improvement, including delays in communicating employee status changes, inconsistencies in tracking leave balances and errors in employee payments. Some delays resulted in overpayments, which were subsequently recovered, while two employees were underpaid upon retirement or resignation.
The auditors classified the district's payroll control risk as moderate and recommended stronger oversight and more consistent procedures.

Assistant Superintendent for Business Andrew Lennon outlined a corrective action plan that includes clearer deadlines for payroll changes, additional reviews of retirement payments and a formal payroll procedures manual, expected to be completed by the end of January.

Capital Improvements and Electric Bus Updates

Director of Facilities Nick Ferraro presented a five-year capital plan identifying approximately $1.9 million in proposed projects for 2027-28, including classroom renovations, air conditioning replacement and infrastructure improvements.

The district also reported progress on its $101 million capital bond, with initial work at Greenacres and Quaker Ridge potentially beginning next summer, pending state approval.

Meanwhile, three of the district's four electric school buses are operating, while the fourth is undergoing warranty repairs. Charging facilities continue to rely on a temporary diesel generator because Con Edison has delayed electrical upgrades until the first quarter of 2027. The district also expects to add an electric minibus and is considering two additional chargers.

School Lunch Program Draws Continued Parent Concerns

The district's school lunch program remained a topic of discussion, with parents raising concerns about meal quality, nutrition, portion sizes and communication with families.
During public comment, Edgewood parent Su Kai Chin described her frustration after her children complained about school lunches and frequently came home hungry. She recalled finding that chicken nuggets her daughter brought home were "heavily breaded with very little chicken and appeared highly processed."

Chin said she had heard similar complaints from families at other elementary schools, including reports of insufficient portions and menu items that were not served as advertised.

"The feedback points to recurring concern about nutrition, insufficient portion, high price, and actual quality represented," she said.

While acknowledging the district's staffing and facilities challenges, Chin urged the Board to establish a clearer process for evaluating the program, including greater transparency and opportunities for parent input before future decisions are made.

Assistant Superintendent for Business Andrew Lennon provided an update on the October 29 food service committee meeting, explaining that the district is working to improve communication, address staffing shortages and review the nutritional content of meals. He also noted that Fox Meadow, Edgewood and Heathcote receive meals prepared at the high school's central kitchen, creating additional logistical challenges.

Lennon acknowledged growing community frustration and indicated that the district may reconsider its current food service arrangement sooner than originally planned.
"I think there's a lot of community frustration and concern about the program," Lennon said. "If we need to look at that sooner, we will."

The district plans to continue meeting with parents and the food service committee as it considers possible improvements and future contract decisions.

Other Board Updates

The Board continued discussing a proposed change to its check-signing policy but did not take action. Members also reviewed the possible addition of Fahrenheit 451 to the seventh-grade curriculum, connecting the novel's themes to the middle school's ongoing discussions about technology and digital balance.

Board reports included encouraging results from the 2026 PRIDE survey, which showed lower reported rates of alcohol, marijuana and other substance use among Scarsdale teenagers compared with previous surveys.

Superintendent Patrick also recognized the accomplishments of fall athletic teams, including sectional championships in girls swimming and diving, girlsโ€™ cross country and boysโ€™ volleyball.

The Board concluded with routine business, including approval of budget transfers and donations supporting school field trips and athletic transportation.

Watch the meeting here.

Add comment

Submit